A Farewell After 27 Years

With a heavy heart, I am closing Caay after 27 beautiful years in Nashville. James and I have decided to step away and take care of our family. To clear the last of the collection, I am holding my final closing sale with discounts of up to 75%. Once they're gone, they're gone — and the doors close for the last time.

Final Farewell Offers

  • Buy 2 — Get Extra 10% Off
  • Buy 3 — Get Extra 15% Off
  • Buy 4 — Get Extra 20% Off
  • Buy 5 — Get Extra 25% Off

*Discounts are applied automatically at checkout & items can be combined from different collections.

Thank you — from Nashville, to every woman across America who made Caay a part of her life. It has been the honor of my life. — Caroline 🤍

Filters
Sort by:

314 products

Save $17.00
Halloween Skeleton Hand Sterling Silver Clip Earrings shine of diamond
Halloween Skeleton Hand Sterling Silver Clip Earrings Sale price$87.00 Regular price$104.00
Save $60.00
Exquisite Emerald Cut & Round Cut Hoop Earrings In Sterling Silver Shineofdiamond
Exquisite Emerald Cut & Round Cut Hoop Earrings In Sterling Silver Sale price$139.00 Regular price$199.00
Save $30.00
Halo Round Cut Sterling Silver Stud Earrings Shineofidamond
Halo Round Cut Sterling Silver Stud Earrings Sale price$119.00 Regular price$149.00
Save $13.00
Heart Cut Sterling Silver Stud Earrings Shineofidamond
Heart Cut Sterling Silver Stud Earrings Sale price$99.00 Regular price$112.00
Save $46.00
Diamond Sterling Silver Stud Earrings Shineofidamond
Sterling Silver Stud Earrings Sale price$113.00 Regular price$159.00
Save $32.00
Four Leaves Clover Stud Earrings Shineofidamond
Four Leaves Clover Stud Earrings Sale price$97.00 Regular price$129.00
Save $30.00
Heart Natural Pearls Sterling Silver Stud Earrings Carly Jewelry
Heart Natural Pearls Sterling Silver Stud Earrings Sale price$99.00 Regular price$129.00
Infinity Pearls Sterling Silver Stud Earrings Carly Jewelry
Infinity Pearls Sterling Silver Stud Earrings Sale price$99.00
Save $17.00
Evil Eye Sterling Silver Stud Earrings Carly Jewelry
Evil Eye Sterling Silver Stud Earrings Sale price$87.00 Regular price$104.00
On sale
D Color Moissanite Round Cut Halo Design Sterling Silver Stud Earrings Shine of Diamond
D Color Moissanite Round Cut Halo Design Sterling Silver Stud Earrings Sale priceFrom $99.00 Regular price$134.00
Cute Floral Sterling Silver Stud Earrings Carly Jewelry
Cute Floral Sterling Silver Stud Earrings Sale price$112.00
On sale
Moissanite Clover Halo Stud Earrings in 925 Sterling Silver Shine of Diamond
Moissanite Clover Halo Stud Earrings in Silver Sale priceFrom $119.00 Regular price$156.00
Save $30.00
Flower Design Stud Earrings Shineofidamond
Flower Design Stud Earrings Sale price$119.00 Regular price$149.00
Save $40.00
Dainty Flower Design Marquise & Pear Cut Sterling Silver Stud Earrings Shineofdiamond
Dainty Flower Design Marquise & Pear Cut Sterling Silver Stud Earrings Sale price$259.00 Regular price$299.00
Save $30.00
Elegant Radiant Cut Sterling Silver Stud Earrings in Multiple Colors Shineofdiamond
Elegant Radiant Cut Sterling Silver Stud Earrings in Multiple Colors Sale price$119.00 Regular price$149.00
On sale
Elegant Heart Cut Sterling Silver Stud Earrings Shineofdiamond
Elegant Heart Cut Sterling Silver Stud Earrings Sale priceFrom $137.00 Regular price$500.00
Save $25.00
Luxury Rectangular Design Radiant Cut Silver Stud Earrings shineofdiamond
Luxury Rectangular Design Radiant Cut Silver Stud Earrings Sale price$124.00 Regular price$149.00
Save $40.00
Moissanite Round Cut Bezel Stud Earrings In Sterling Silver Shineofdiamond
Moissanite Round Cut Bezel Stud Earrings In Sterling Silver Sale price$129.00 Regular price$169.00
On sale
Gorgeous Round Cut Moissanite Screw Back Sterling Silver Stud Earrings shineofdiamond
Gorgeous Round Cut Moissanite Screw Back Sterling Silver Stud Earrings Sale priceFrom $99.00 Regular price$224.00
On sale
Exquisite Moissanite Stud Earrings In Sterling Silver shine of diamond
Exquisite Moissanite Stud Earrings In Sterling Silver Sale priceFrom $148.00 Regular price$199.00
On sale
Gorgeous Round Cut Moissanite Stud Earrings In Sterling Silver shineofdiamond
Gorgeous Round Cut Moissanite Stud Earrings In Sterling Silver Sale priceFrom $99.00 Regular price$224.00
Save $25.00
Emerald Cut Stud Earrings In Sterling Silver Shineofdiamond
Emerald Cut Stud Earrings In Sterling Silver Sale price$124.00 Regular price$149.00
Save $100.00
Elegant Pearl Shell Design Drop Earrings in Sterling Silver Shineofdiamond
Elegant Pearl Shell Design Drop Earrings in Sterling Silver Sale price$99.00 Regular price$199.00
Save $40.00
Opal Halo Sterling Silver Drop Earrings Carly Jewelry
Opal Halo Sterling Silver Drop Earrings Sale price$89.00 Regular price$129.00